SU heart punch and EK success heart punch

[jor]

There is probably a thread, but I'm in a hurry! LOL

Does anyone know if the large SU heart punch matches any of the EK Success punches? Like their large medium (?) heart punch or the whale of a heart punch? I don't want to order something if I already have something that works!

[jor]

anyone?

[GreenDragonLady]

I only have the SU heart punch, so I have nothing to compare it to!

[craftymomto2]

Could you punch one out and take it with you to compare? That is what I've done to make sure I don't buy the same size. Or take a photocopy of the punch out from pages 186 and 187? They look to be the actual size in the catalog.

[GreenDragonLady]

Yes, the punches are shown actual size in the catty.

[Tami Mayberry]

I don't have SU punches so not much help there. The EK Whale of a punch measures 1 9/16" tall and 1 11/16" at the widest part. The EK medium heart measures approx. 1" tall and 1" at the widest part.

[babydal57]

The EK Success Whale of a Punch is a bit narrower than the SU heart punch. The SU punch is a bit rounder and wider at the top. But they are probably no more than 1/8" different.

I bought both to match different heart sets. I don't think that they'd work interchangeably. The border around the stamp would be off enough to look wonky.