I have this very nice set from Serendipity stamps. Gorgeous image every time, and looks great colored in or embossed in gold.
Serendipity Stamps Bread and Chalice Cling Set
Also look for a wine glass punch! I have a small one, maybe one inch tall? I use it with gold paper and add a little 1/4" white or cream circle for a host at the top. Makes an effective chalice and host. I have a few communion examples in my gallery.
Personally I would never drop $45 on a die!